Metadata interoperability: semantic problems
•Different names (and languages) for the same thing (journal_article vs SerialArticleWork)
•Data elements at different levels of speciality (title vs FullTitle,AlternativeTitle).
•Different allowed values for elements (pii vs not pii)
•Data at different levels of granularity (journal_article vs SerialArticleWork/SerialArticleVersion).
•Data in different structures (article as attribute of journal or vice versa).
•Data from different sources (local codes vs ONIX codes).
•Contextual meaning (DOI of what…?)
•Different representation (1 title vs n titles).
•Different mandatory requirements (ISSN mandatory vs optional).
•Schemas are being updated all the time.
All this is tricky one-to-one. Many-to-many it is a nightmare.
•A common, structured, Data Dictionary can solve the problem
•Indecs (and subsequent development) has done so: now used by DOI
•doi>